261 North Chillicothe Street

Plain City, OH 43064

$539,900 (sold: 5/30/2025) Listing #265818
3 Beds 2 Baths 2,591 sq ft Year Built: 1900 Residential Status: Sold

Charming Turn-of-the-Century Home with Modern Comforts & Timeless Elegance. Step into a perfect blend of historic charm and contemporary convenience in this beautifully preserved circa 1900 residence. This 3-bedroom, 2-bath gem offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of architectural history thoughtfully updated for today's lifestyle. From the moment you arrive, you'll be captivated by the home's original millwork, intricate moldings, and classic pocket doors that speak to long forgotten craftsmanship. Soaring ceilings and generously sized windows flood the home with natural light, enhancing its warm and inviting ambiance. The updated kitchen seamlessly blends form and function, featuring modern appliances, granite counters, period-appropriate subway tiled backsplash and ample amounts of stylish cabinetry all while maintaining the home's vintage aesthetic. Enjoy the peace of mind that comes with a brand-new roof, 2 new zoned HVAC systems, new tankless hot water heater and a new whole-house water filtration system, ensuring comfort and efficiency year-round. Both full bathrooms are tastefully updated, offering spa-like finishes without sacrificing the home's historic character. Each of the three spacious bedrooms provides comfort and flexibility, with the private entrance 3rd floor attic bedroom WOWs as the perfect space for a rec room/teen hang out space. Out back, the spacious green yard offers room to garden, entertain, or simply relax. The property is fully fenced, featuring a new gated drive adding an extra layer of privacy and security. And perhaps best of all this gorgeous home sits on the parade route while also being just a short stroll to local shops, cafes, restaurants, and the Plain City Aquatic Center giving you the best of both worlds: classic charm in a vibrant, walkable neighborhood.

Interior Features

Square Feet 2,591

Exterior Features

Lot Size 0.24 acres
Courtesy of Bobbie Jo Krouse, NextHome Experience
This content last updated on 12/19/2025 11:39 AM. Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available.

Inquire On This Property

Please fill out the form below and I will get back to you regarding your questions as promptly as possible.

Bobbie Jo Krouse

Bobbie Jo Krouse Agent

NextHome Experience Worthington

Photo of Bobbie Jo Krouse
OH License #: 2013002870 Direct: 614.813.8840
Expertise Types: Buyer Broker, New Homes, Relocation, Residential, Land, Condominiums, Co-Op, Residential Investment, Short Sale, Probate, Single Family Homes, Townhomes, Second Homes
Professional Designations: e-Pro, REALTOR